Best Non-Metal Album: Wasting Light (Foo Fighters)
This award is basically my venue to talk about albums I enjoyed this year that aren't metal, and I enjoyed Wasting Light the most. This album contains the energy of your typical FF release while also delivering a decent mix of mellow, down-to-earth moments. Its amazing how these song that were written to be played in arenas were recorded in Dave Grohl's garage on tapes and sound as good as they do. This reinforces the idea that it only takes a couple of dudes with some talent to make great music and that you don't necessarily need the latest recording technology to make it sound good.
Runner Up: Alpocalypse ("Weird Al" Yankovic)
Most Disappointing Album: Post Mortem (Black Tide)
When these guys were forced to play the main stage at Ozzfest in '07 because some of their members were under 21 and could not play on the Jägermeister Stage, they showed some real potential. After their debut album, Light From Above, was released, songs like "Shockwave' and "Warriors of Time" suggested this band could go on to bigger and better things. Well, all of that goodwill was pretty much destroyed (at least for me) when their sophomore effort, Post Mortem, decided to turn the band into a processed piece of pop-metal garbage that would make even the likes of Bullet for My Valentine scoff. While the album isn't god-awful, not one song stands out to me. Everything about this album is dull and forgettable, with only a few decent solo's thrown in. It's a shame this band decided not to continue in the path the first album set and instead join the overrated sensation that is pop-metal. Maybe they can redeem themselves with the next one. I highly doubt it.
Runner Up: Th1rt3en (Megadeth) *Please Note*: Even though this album was slightly disappointing compared to their previous releases, you should still totally listen to this one. There just weren’t that many disappointing albums this year for me so that’s why I included it.
Worst Album: LuLu (Lou Reed/Metallica)
Lou Reed: "Hey guys! I'm incredibly old and have little to no artistic integrity left. How about I read off a bunch of nonsense I wrote and you guys can play over it?"
James: "Sounds good to me! I am the table, herp derp!"
Lars: "Since I'm responsible for the majority of bad decisions Metallica's made over the years and why a lot of our former fans hate us, I obviously endorse this wholeheartedly!"
Kirk: "Do I have to play any solos? No? Perfect!"
Rob: "I don't get payed enough for this."
If someone were to ask me "whats wrong with this album?", I would respond with "what's right with this album!?". The opening track alone with it's boring, repetitive riffs on top of listening to a decrepit old man spewing a bunch of gibberish was enough to make me never want to listen to this again. The rest of the "album" follows this trend of Metallica basically having a bunch of jam sessions while Lou tries to remember why he agreed to do this in the first place. What's worse, not only do these songs overstay their welcome, they refuse to leave! The closing track, "Junior Dad", takes 5 minutes to end! Its almost like the album is saying, "we're going to make you suffer for as long as we can, even when you think its over!".
So congratulations, guys. You have successfully achieved a possible low-point in your career. And congratulations, James. You are the table.
Runner Up: Post Mortem (Black Tide)
2011's Album of the Year: Worship Music (Anthrax)
Big shocker, I know. Even if I did make it seem predictable, that does not mean Worship Music is any less deserving of being this year's best album than it already was. The years it took to complete the record in addition to the changing of singers and overall uncertainty of the band made listening to how it great it is all the more satisfying. Everything about it is what you would want from a straight-up metal album. The guitars are heavy, the drums are intense, the bass grooves, and Joey Belladonna's return helps restore the classic Anthrax sound that has been missing from the last few albums. I could go on and on as to why this is not only the best album released this year, but one of the best albums in Anthrax's career. Instead, I'll just tell you to go listen to it so you can better understand what I'm talking about.
Runners Up:
Dystopia (Iced Earth)
You've heard me praise this album enough already, so I'll be brief. The riffs are classic. The choruses are epic. I miss Matt, but Stu is great. It's Iced Earth. It's Jon Schaffer. It's awesome.
Iconoclast (Symphony X)
Symphony X is one of those bands that seems to be getting better with each album, and that's saying a lot considering they've been around for almost 20 years now. The opening title track sums up how well the band can combine neo-classical guitars (thanks to Michael Romeo) with progressive arrangements. The guitar is the main driving force with this record, producing some amazingly heavy riffs with a great deal of melody. Other highlights, including "End of Innocence" and "Heretic", make this a solid album all around.
That's all she wrote! Thanks for joining me in the first MAYEA Awards. I promise that next year's will be bigger and better, so look forward to that. I'd also like to thank everyone for supporting me this year and hope you will continue to read the site in the years to come. I have some new things planned for 2012 that I'd like to share soon. In the meantime, have a great New Year!













